Gender ideology and medical interventions for minors are being debunked by psychiatrists, with evidence showing that sex is established at conception and recognized at birth, and that there is no scientific basis for the claim that it is assigned at birth.
Countries have banned medical interventions for minors related to gender ideology due to the risks outweighing the benefits, and caution is advised for children and adolescents undergoing gender therapies.
There is no standard medical care for transgender patients, and veteran clinicians with wisdom and experience are being ignored for disagreeing with the current narrative on gender ideology and medical interventions
Questions to inspire discussion
-
What is the evidence on when sex is established?
—The evidence shows that sex is established at conception and recognized at birth.
-
Why have some countries banned medical interventions for minors related to gender ideology?
—Countries have banned these interventions due to the risks outweighing the benefits.
-
Is there a standard medical care for transgender patients?
—No, there is no standard medical care for transgender patients.
-
Why are veteran clinicians being ignored in the current narrative on gender ideology and medical interventions?
—Veteran clinicians with wisdom and experience are being ignored for disagreeing with the current narrative.
-
What is the scientific basis for the claim that sex is assigned at birth?
—There is no scientific basis for the claim that sex is assigned at birth.
Key insights
- 💼 Dr. Miriam Grossman is a board certified psychiatrist with 45 years of experience, bringing a wealth of knowledge and expertise to the discussion on gender ideology.
- 🤔 "Sex is established at conception and it's recognized at Birth if not earlier."
- 🇫🇮🇸🇪 Finland and Sweden have implemented strict limitations on medical interventions for minors, highlighting concerns about the long-term effects of puberty blockers.
- 💉 "The risks of anti-puberty and hormone treatment for those under 18 currently outweigh the possible benefits."
- 💔 "The therapies cause doctors in New Zealand and Australia have published...placing their kids at risk of suicide regarding that point of view."
- 💥 "There is a fierce debate in the medical field regarding transgender care, with prominent figures opposing the current narrative and medical interventions."
- 💔 "There is no evidence of long-term benefit but there is evidence of harm" in the treatment at the gender clinic.
Clips
-
00:00 👩⚕️ Psychiatrist debunks gender ideology lies and responds to Dr McNamara's use of the phrase "sex assigned at birth."
-
00:24 🚫 Sex is not assigned at birth, it is established at conception and recognized at birth, and the claim that it is assigned at birth is without scientific basis, as social and medical interventions are the only evidence-based treatment.
-
01:13 🚨 Countries have banned medical interventions for minors related to gender ideology due to the risks outweighing the benefits.
-
02:09 🔍 Norway and France have made policy changes and medical caution is advised for children and adolescents undergoing gender therapies.
-
02:33 🚫 Kids in multiple countries are not in need of gender transition treatments, but rather psychotherapy.
-
03:23 🚫 There is no standard medical care for transgender patients, as there is a fierce debate in the field with prominent figures on the opposite side of Dr McNamara's position.
-
04:07 🚫 Veteran clinicians with wisdom and experience are ignored for disagreeing with the current narrative on gender ideology and medical interventions, with evidence of harm and lack of long-term benefit, as stated by a whistleblower from a children's gender clinic.
------------------------------------- 0:5:7 2023-06-26T22:45:40Z