There are significant risks and potential harm associated with gender therapies for minors, and the current narrative surrounding transgender care ignores dissenting opinions from experienced doctors
Questions to inspire discussion
-
What are the risks associated with gender therapies for minors?
—The video highlights that there are significant risks and potential harm associated with gender therapies for minors, which are often overlooked in the current narrative surrounding transgender care.
-
Why does the current narrative surrounding transgender care ignore dissenting opinions?
—The video suggests that experienced doctors who have dissenting opinions on transgender care are often ignored in the current narrative, which can lead to a lack of balanced information and potential harm for minors.
-
What is the key idea of the video?
—The key idea of the video is that there are significant risks and potential harm associated with gender therapies for minors, and the current narrative surrounding transgender care ignores dissenting opinions from experienced doctors.
-
Who is affected by the potential harm associated with gender therapies for minors?
—The potential harm associated with gender therapies for minors can affect the minors themselves, as well as their families and communities.
-
What does the video suggest about the current narrative surrounding transgender care?
—The video suggests that the current narrative surrounding transgender care often overlooks dissenting opinions from experienced doctors, which can lead to a lack of balanced information and potential harm for minors.
Key insights
- 💼 Dr. Miriam Grossman is a board certified psychiatrist with 45 years of experience, bringing a wealth of knowledge and expertise to the discussion on gender ideology.
- 🤔 "Sex is established at conception and it's recognized at Birth if not earlier."
- 🇫🇮🇸🇪 Finland and Sweden have implemented strict limitations on medical interventions for minors, highlighting concerns about the long-term effects of puberty blockers.
- 💉 "The risks of anti-puberty and hormone treatment for those under 18 currently outweigh the possible benefits."
- 💔 "The therapies cause doctors in New Zealand and Australia have published...placing their kids at risk of suicide regarding that point of view."
- 💥 "There is a fierce debate in the medical field regarding transgender care, with prominent figures opposing the current narrative and medical interventions."
- 💔 "There is no evidence of long-term benefit but there is evidence of harm" in the treatment at the gender clinic.
Clips
-
00:00 💡 Dr. Miriam Grossman, a psychiatrist with 45 years of experience, responds to Dr. McNamara during her opening statement at a hearing.
-
00:26 👩⚕️ Sex is not assigned at birth, but established at conception, and using the phrase "sex assigned at birth" is misleading and scientifically incorrect.
-
01:20 💡 Countries that have banned medical interventions for minors based on gender ideology have not seen an increase in suicides or mental health issues, as warned by the speaker.
-
01:51 💡 The risks of anti-puberty and hormone treatment for those under 18 outweigh the benefits, leading to severe restrictions on care in the UK, policy changes in Norway, and a warning from the National Academy of Medicine in France.
-
02:36 👩⚕️ Doctors in multiple countries, including New Zealand, Australia, and Finland, reject gender therapies that interrupt development and pose risks to children's well-being.
-
03:25 👩⚕️ There is a debate in the medical field regarding transgender care, with prominent doctors who have treated transgender patients for years being ignored because they disagree with the current narrative.
-
04:25 💡 There is no evidence of long-term benefit and evidence of harm in gender clinics, and our tax dollars should not support such a perilous experiment.
------------------------------------- 0:5:22 2023-08-30T07:24:05Z