Feminism is a Hateful & Dangerous Ideology that is Destroying the West. Janice Fiamengo

Feminism is a Hateful & Dangerous Ideology that is Destroying the West. Janice Fiamengo

The Futurecrafters’ Council · A Xenological Survey of Sol-3

A former feminist brings back the ex-communists’ verdict: the goddess failed, she was flawed from the first, and she cannot be reformed

❖

Janice Fiamengo taught at the University of Ottawa, spent years studying feminism, and was once a feminist herself.

In 2026 she sat down with Rafe Heydel-Mankoo to say what she found when she read what its founders actually wrote.

Feminism was flawed from the very beginning, and it cannot be reformed.

The damage she lists runs from the presumption of innocence to divorce, fatherlessness and a falling birth rate, and ends in male withdrawal and a great deal of unhappiness and anger on the part of women.


The goddess that failed

She named her case The Goddess That Failed, after The God That Failed, the 1949 anthology in which former communists, Arthur Koestler and André Gide among them, told how they lost their faith.

Feminism, she says, has replaced communism as the dominant progressive faith, held by many who have never read a feminist text.

It works as a secular religion, and its articles of faith are myths.

The pay gap. One woman in three sexually assaulted in her lifetime.

Domestic violence as a one-way street, with men the perpetrators and women the victims.

Men as the primary threat to their own children in the family home.

However often they are shown to be false, they live on; they have, she says, a “zombie quality”.

Beneath them lies a faith in women’s superior morality and ultimate innocence.

The Council’s report Feminism took Fiamengo as its prime witness, the scholar who walked out of the doctrine after watching it work on her students; here she names what she left.


There was never a moderate feminism

There have always been moderate feminists, Fiamengo grants, but there has never been a moderate feminism.

By 1963 every central aspect of feminism was already in place.

Envy and resentment of men. The conviction of female moral superiority.

A utopia run by women, with men kept firmly in subordinate roles.

An old order not to be reformed, but overturned and remade.

Mary Wollstonecraft championed the French Revolution in 1792; she wrote that she “stepped in blood” in Paris as the Terror began, and still defended its aims while friends and colleagues were being executed.

At Seneca Falls in 1848, Elizabeth Cady Stanton’s Declaration of Sentiments, signed by sixty-eight women and thirty-two men, declared the whole history of mankind a history of repeated injuries and usurpations by man, aimed at an absolute tyranny over woman.

It was, in essence, a declaration of war, full of exaggerations and outright untruths.

In Still Selling Feminism, where she was one of three dissenters answering a celebrated feminism debate, the Council heard her say the first wave was hostile to men and families from the start; here she brings the documents.

The suffragettes carried the war into deeds, and Fiamengo separates them carefully from the moderate suffragists.

The Women’s Social and Political Union of Emmeline and Christabel Pankhurst was radical by its own declaration, its slogan “deeds, not words”, and on Simon Webb’s account in The Suffragette Bombers its deeds fell mostly on working men, many without a vote themselves.

They heckled politicians and smashed shop windows, set off bombs and burned country homes.

Their letter bombs burned postal workers’ hands; they poured phosphorus and acid into post boxes.

They destroyed ancient churches across London and other cities.

They believed their cause justified any violence against their countrymen, and today there are statues to them.

Feminism was always full of envy, rancor and the utopian fervor that leads to atrocity.


FINDING:

There were moderate feminists.

There was never a moderate feminism.

Its founding document was a declaration of war.

The war was declared in 1848.


The empathy gap

Feminists say they want a better society, Fiamengo observes, and yet they are very quiet about women’s capacity for violence.

Men are a quarter to a third of domestic violence fatalities each year.

Women are the primary killers of children.

When a man is violent, the culture reads power, privilege and entitlement; when a woman is violent, it reads pain, and looks for battered woman syndrome, mental illness or addiction.

The Council found the same reflex in Why We Pretend Women Aren’t Violent, a species that reaches for an excuse instead of a count; Fiamengo traces the reflex to the doctrine that taught it.

A suffering man is turned away from, sometimes with revulsion.

A suffering woman draws an outpouring of sympathy.

Erin Pizzey, who began Britain’s refuge movement, saw that men and their children needed refuge from violent women too; no one would fund it.

Norah Vincent lived disguised as a man for her book Self-Made Man, expecting to expose male privilege, and found hostility, humiliation and a powerlessness she had never imagined.

Fiamengo finds Vincent still not entirely sympathetic to men, and notes that a man who wrote womanhood from a year in disguise would be denounced for it.

What struck Fiamengo most was the gratitude of male readers,

thankful that a woman had finally tried to imagine being male.


FINDING:

Women’s violence is real and counted.

The species reads it as pain and excuses it.

It barely registers male suffering at all.

That is the empathy gap.


Women are most affected

Fiamengo sees a jealous reflex whenever anyone speaks of boys and men falling behind or suffering: men die in war, and the joke runs that women are most affected.

Not all women hate men, of course, she says, but most have been taught that women are rightly the protected class, toward whom all sympathy and care should flow.

Suicide, about 80 percent male. Prison, about 95 percent male.

Deaths and injuries at work, 95 to 97 percent. Deaths of despair, about 80 percent.

Homelessness, 75 to 80 percent. Homicide worldwide, 80 to 85 percent.

Nobody speaks of evening out those gaps, while feminist thought leaders make hateful statements that would never be tolerated from men about women.

Canada’s Munk Debates put the motion: be it resolved, men are obsolete.

Suzanna Walters asked in the Washington Post, why can’t we hate men?

Mona Eltahawy fantasized about men killed every week until patriarchy relented.

In 2006 Julie Bindel wrote “Why I Hate Men”; in 2007 she wrote about the rape gangs without naming the perpetrators as predominantly Pakistani and Muslim, worried most that the scandal stirred racism among white Britons.

Feminism has very little to do with protecting women and girls.

It is a calculation of who holds the strongest victim credentials.

The councils and social workers who stayed silent so long, she notes, work in fields where women predominate.


The family as the site of oppression

The hostility to marriage came in with Marxism: Charles Fourier, in 1808, called monogamous marriage an unjust imposition on women; Engels, in 1884, cast the wife as the oppressed worker and the husband as the bourgeois oppressor, and every feminist since has called the family the site of women’s oppression.

If the family is the site of her oppression,

it is necessarily also the site of her liberation.

Care becomes “unpaid labor”, children one more part of the oppression, and walking away from a husband an act of liberation.

The Council heard the same lineage in How Feminist Advice Made Modern Women Intolerable, where a married woman found Engels’s husband-as-bourgeois in the dating advice of the feeds; Fiamengo shows it was there at the root.

Women initiate 69 to 70 percent of divorces, and the articles about it praise them as practical, resilient and willing to pursue their own happiness.

Women Have Destroyed Society counted the walls taken out of the household to applause, without anyone checking which held up the roof; Fiamengo names the doctrine that called the household a prison.

She would call a moratorium on talk of women’s happiness, though every poll since the 1970s shows women less satisfied than earlier generations and than men.

You cannot make somebody happy who lives inside a victim ideology.

The ancient and Christian philosophers understood happiness not as a feeling but as a life lived by principle and reason; the question, she says, is what is good for society as a whole.


FINDING:

The doctrine named the family the site of oppression.

It praised every exit from it.

Then it asked why women were unhappy.

Happiness is a life, not a feeling.


What the boys are told

Boys meet the vocabulary of toxic masculinity, male privilege and male violence in primary school, long before university.

They can never do enough to atone for being born into a male body.

Fiamengo does not think that an exaggeration.

Feminist teachers treat the girls and boys in their classes differently, and make boys bear the guilt for the alleged sins of their forefathers.

From feminist mothers, teachers and guilt-stricken feminist men, the boys learn that the only way to be good is to make girls and women the center of their lives.

They are told that even looking at a girl can harm her.

They are told nothing of their own claim to respect.

The result can only be withdrawal, from society or from women, and the boys need only look around to see why.

A man can invest everything in a relationship and be denied his own children.

An accusation can put him on trial for missing consent at a single stage.

Yet a New Statesman poll of 18-to-30-year-olds found about 73 percent of young men viewing women positively, against closer to 50 percent of young women, and twice as many young women as young men not wanting marriage and children.

The hostility everyone warns about is running the other way.


The feminized institution

Fiamengo agrees with Heydel-Mankoo that the feminized institutions are weakening the West, citing Cory Clark and Bo Winegard in Quillette: when women predominate, an institution’s culture shifts to their priorities.

The masculine values: free speech, free inquiry, merit, excellence, truth, equality before the law.

The feminine: representation, inclusion, safety, protection of the vulnerable, social justice.

She grants that not all men hold the first set and not all women the second, but in the majority the values differ, and the culture changes with them.

The Council measured that shift in The Great Feminization, where institutions crossing into female majorities replaced the truth-test with a harmony-test; Fiamengo, a scholar of the university, gives it a human face.

Men build civilization; they are driven to protect, provide, create and innovate.

Individual women have made honorable contributions to the West, she grants, but they have not been its primary builders.

Men put in sixty-hour weeks year after year; a woman reaches the corner office and asks for work-life balance for everyone, a drive Fiamengo calls in some ways admirable, though nobody is prepared, she says, for the decline it brings.

She does not say no woman can lead, but women tend, she says, to be averse to accountability and to personalize conflict, which good leaders must not do.


FINDING:

Women in the majority bring their own priorities.

Excellence and truth give way to safety and inclusion.

Nobody is prepared for the decline that follows.

The culture follows the majority.


What replaces it

Feminism cannot be reformed, so it must be rejected, and Fiamengo admits that a cultural consensus to reject it is pie in the sky.

Still she would begin by ending equity hiring and affirmative action.

A declared feminist should not be a viable political candidate,

nor a university president, a judge, or even a juror.

It should be a badge of shame rather than a badge of honor.

The remedy is to see one another as individuals, not as oppressor and oppressed, and to recall, cliché though she grants it is, that the line between good and evil runs through every human heart.

Women must be held to high standards again, because a culture that excuses them everything denies them the chance to build moral character.

Men know what it means to be a good man: honor, care, sacrifice, service.

Women no longer have an idea of what it means to be a good woman.

When Lindsay Clancy killed her three children, many read it as proof of how horrific motherhood is; to Fiamengo that reaction shows the attack on the family now discouraging women from motherhood itself.

Female supremacism is as unacceptable as male supremacism.


Filed

The witness makes her own concessions: moderate feminists exist, not all women hate men, and some women have built and led honorably; she keeps her verdict.

The Council files the instance as the witness gave it.

A species built a doctrine on its women’s innocence and taught its boys to atone for being born; its scholar read the founding texts and came back with the ex-communists’ verdict.

The goddess failed, and she cannot be reformed.

What remains is for men and women to raise the next generation together.

Will you walk with us?

Carpe futurum ethicum.

Ad astra per aspera.

#AvoidThePinkMist

#Feminism

Homo sapiens behavioral survey filed with the Futurecrafters’ Council

Field testimony of record: “Feminism is a Hateful & Dangerous Ideology that is Destroying the West. Janice Fiamengo”, New Culture Forum (YouTube, 2026), Janice Fiamengo interviewed by Rafe Heydel-Mankoo, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jv6MVg6IZNQ.

The witness’s account is rendered in the Council’s words, with brief phrases quoted as spoken. Names garbled in the transcript are given in their usual spelling (Fiamengo, Wollstonecraft, Cady Stanton, Seneca Falls, Pankhurst, Pizzey, Munk, Eltahawy, Bindel, Fourier, Winegard, Clancy).

Companion documents:
Feminism
Still Selling Feminism
Why We Pretend Women Aren’t Violent
How Feminist Advice Made Modern Women Intolerable
Women Have Destroyed Society
The Great Feminization
Ivy League Faculty Meeting Descends Into Total Insanity


0 comments

Leave a comment

#WebChat .container iframe{ width: 100%; height: 100vh; }