The Futurecrafters’ Council · A Xenological Survey of Sol-3
A physician reads one young woman’s crime, then the species’ own figures on who strikes whom at home
❖
We have to protect women from domestic violence,
because men are so aggressive and violent.
Are they?
Dr. Hannah Spier, medical doctor and psychotherapist, asked the question on her channel Psychobabble.
The species compares the sexes, she says, by setting male physical aggression against female relational aggression: the rumour, the exclusion, the damaged reputation.
That comparison hides a second question.
Are women really so much less physically violent, and if so, by how much?
She came to it through one case, and then went to the figures.
The Council enters both as she gave them.
The girl in the car
In July 2022 Mackenzie Shirilla, then seventeen, had her twenty-year-old boyfriend and his nineteen-year-old friend in her car.
She accelerated to about 100 miles an hour and drove straight into a brick wall.
Both young men died.
She survived, injured.
Her defence called it a medical emergency, a blood-pressure disorder.
If she had meant to kill them, it asked, why would she be in the car herself?
She was convicted of their murder and sentenced to fifteen years to life.
The case has since become a phenomenon: a Netflix documentary, The Crash, interviews from prison during her appeal, and a stream of people who knew her before and inside.
I think that shows how desperate we are
to put this into a framework we understand.
Here is a very attractive young girl, a TikTok influencer.
The prosecution painted a darker picture.
It combed through almost 93,000 text messages, police video and social-media posts, and argued that the crash was calculated and intentional, and that she had rehearsed the route.
She idealised the mean girl and wanted to be Regina George, of the film Mean Girls.
Friends from before describe her as a bully.
So, Dr. Spier notes, do the girls in prison.
A badge of honour
That struck her as odd.
People with antisocial traits usually mask them to fit in and avoid being found out.
When women make moves of interpersonal dominance, she says, they cloak them.
Oh, I just worry that it’s too much Botox.
I just worry for her.
A reputation is blackened under cover of concern.
We don’t wear that kind of behaviour
like a badge of honour, of superiority,
as she clearly did.
Dr. Spier reads cluster B traits in what is on the record.
Two weeks before the crash, the boyfriend, Dominic Russo, called his mother to complain that she was driving erratically, and a friend heard her scream that she was going to wreck the car right now.
She uses the car as a weapon,
as an emotional terror tool, a means of intimidation.
That, she says, is volatility, impulsivity and intense emotion, escalation used to move someone into action, and it fits cluster B rather than cold psychopathy.
Much was made of the five seconds she held the accelerator without braking, steering precisely into the wall, which some read as the missing startle response of a cold psychopath.
Dr. Spier has seen the same in borderline girls: so fixed on the outcome they want, in the moment, that they become utterly reckless with their own safety.
The boyfriend had reportedly tried to end the relationship.
If I can’t have you,
no one can have you,
and we’re all just going to die.
She calls it a narcissistic injury, and ego protection.
FINDING:
The species looked for the illness that explains her.
It overlooked the intent the evidence showed.
The framework was built to excuse.
Performative grief
Where the low compassion and agreeableness of borderline, antisocial and psychopathic traits show plainly, Dr. Spier says, is in what came next.
From the hospital she posted online tributes as the grieving girlfriend.
Then she went to a concert with friends and posted things that were clearly not those of a grieving girlfriend, and spoke of pursuing a modelling career soon after.
She kills two people and clearly just goes on with her life.
Actions speak louder than words.
Then the jailhouse calls.
In one, she asks her mother to change her Instagram bio to Free Kenzie; her mother warns that it may look bad, and agrees.
No one in the call, Dr. Spier notes, asks her to think about what she has done.
She is worried that she is bored.
In the courtroom video of her sentencing, she says, she is crying for her own fate, not for what she did.
In another call, mother and daughter laugh that the case has made the Daily Mail in England, and wonder whether Kim Kardashian might reach out.
At no point does she encourage moral accountability.
Dr. Spier would be very surprised if this young woman did not have a history of being shielded, excused and kept from consequences.
In her experience, that kind of parenting contributes more to borderline development than trauma or a difficult childhood.
At the end of the day, she’s a violent woman,
and there are many more of them than we like to admit.
Gender symmetry
Then the figures, starting with intimate partner violence.
A study of 18,761 opposite-sex relationships found physical violence in nearly 24 per cent of them, and in 49.7 per cent of those the violence ran both ways.
Broader analyses of who initiates agree.
Bidirectional: 57.9 per cent.
Female on male only: 28.3 per cent.
Male on female only: 13.8 per cent.
Yet the species’ first reflex, when a woman strikes, is to ask why.
It must have been self-defence; she must have been in an abusive relationship.
When the reality-television figure Taylor Frankie Paul threw a chair across a room, the first question, she says, was what he had done to provoke her.
When women are asked, they answer differently.
A 2007 study of the reasons women give for physical aggression in dating relationships found the common triggers were anger and hurt feelings, not self-defence.
Nor is this new.
The National Family Violence Survey of 1975 found assault by male partners at 12 per cent and by female partners at 11.6 per cent.
Severe assault: kicking, punching, choking, attacking with objects.
Men: 3.8 per cent.
Women: 4.6 per cent.
Those differences, she says, are statistically insignificant.
It starts early: recent studies from Canada find that teenage boys suffer more physical dating violence from their partners than teenage girls do.
The Council heard this witness describe the wife who has moved her husband into the out-group in Why Your Wife Starts Treating You Like the Enemy.
FINDING:
Where both sexes share a home,
the violence is nearly symmetric.
Only the sympathy is not.
One sex is asked why. The other is asked nothing.
A false equivalence
The standard reply is the crime table: men commit 85 to 90 per cent of murders and most violent crime, so men must be inherently more violent.
Wrong.
This is a false equivalence.
Men commit the great majority of crimes against strangers, she says: gang violence, robbery, career criminality.
Bring in interpersonal and domestic violence, and the picture changes.
Look where women are in close proximity and in control, she says, as in the care of the elderly and of children.
National adult maltreatment data from 2019 show elder abuse committed more often by women than by men.
The worst is the killing of children.
A Bureau of Justice Statistics report on family murders found mothers were 55 per cent of the defendants in cases where parents killed their children.
Studies from Finland put mothers at 59 per cent of filicides.
Narrow it to neonaticide, the killing of a baby in its first twenty-four hours.
A systematic review of child-homicide perpetrators across thirteen countries found that parents commit all of it, and mothers effectively all of that.
Where women hold the power
and no one is watching,
the figures change sex.
The Council has counted the children the species did not let live in Mourn The Unborn.
FINDING:
Male violence is counted where men gather.
Female violence happens where women rule:
the nursery, the care home, the kitchen.
The table measured the street, not the home.
The excuse machine
When a man commits a horrific crime, Dr. Spier says, society blames his inherent aggression.
That account then drives policy.
It gives women special treatment, and it becomes an argument against a woman staying home or depending on a husband: do not depend on a man, because you are likely to become a victim of his aggression.
Women are very much as capable of physical violence.
For a woman, the species reaches at once for an outside cause.
Her age.
Social media.
Postpartum depression.
Extreme stress.
Lack of support.
A bad husband.
Each excuse moves the cause outside her.
She becomes the setting in which something else acted: a hormone, a feed, a husband, a hard week.
A man is granted no such setting; his act is taken as the truth about him and about his sex.
In the Shirilla case it was her youth and social media, though countless girls live on the same feeds and do not kill anyone.
We immediately look for an excuse,
rather than acknowledging women’s capacity for violence.
The Council has entered what happens to a civilization that steers by feeling rather than by count in The Great Filter.
FINDING:
A cause found outside her is an acquittal.
A cause found inside him is a policy.
The same act, judged twice.
Filed
The witness began with one young woman and ended with the species’ own surveys.
Both say the same thing.
She drove two young men into a wall and posted the grief.
Half of violent couples strike both ways.
Women initiate alone twice as often as men.
Mothers kill more of their children than fathers.
The newborn has only its mother to fear.
The Council files the instance as the witness gave it.
A species that counts violence only where men gather, and explains it away wherever women hold power, will protect one sex from the other and leave the second unprotected.
The myth of the nonviolent woman is not a finding.
It is the excuse that a finding was never made.
Will you walk with us?
Carpe futurum ethicum.
Ad astra per aspera.
#AvoidThePinkMist
#FemaleViolence
Homo sapiens behavioral survey filed with the Futurecrafters’ Council
Field testimony of record: “The Myth of the Nonviolent Woman”, Dr. Hannah Spier, Psychobabble (2026), https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jlx2E5zwTvQ.
The witness’s account is rendered in the Council’s words, with brief phrases quoted as spoken. Figures are entered as she cited them; the caption’s spellings of the defendant’s name are given as Mackenzie Shirilla.
Companion documents:
Why Your Wife Starts Treating You Like the Enemy
Mourn The Unborn
The Great Filter
Why Women should fear the Manosphere
Women Know EXACTLY What They're Doing
How Female Power Caused The Decline Of The West
The Good Men Did Not Disappear, They Left!
The Reason Women Are SO Susceptible to Groupthink
Feminism is a Hateful & Dangerous Ideology that is Destroying the West. Janice Fiamengo
Caught Hiring a Hitman. Why Did It Take THREE Trials?
The Rise of the Pathological Female
International Men's Day: Why Standing Up for Men Matters More Than Ever
This Is Why Men Cannot Ever Win