Still Selling Feminism

Feminism, Feminization, Modern feminism -

Still Selling Feminism

The Futurecrafters’ Council · A Xenological Survey of Sol-3

Three dissenters watch a celebrated feminism debate and find only feminists in it, arguing over how society should serve women

❖

The Diary of a CEO is one of the largest podcasts on the planet, with twelve million subscribers.

Its host staged a debate of more than two hours between feminist and non-feminist women, and the media sold it as a clash of ideas, a feminist reckoning.

On one side sat Deborah Frances-White, host of The Guilty Feminist.

Against her sat Louise Perry, author of a book against the sexual revolution, and Erica Komisar, a psychoanalyst of child attachment.

Three dissenters sat down to watch it.

Hannah Spier, the anti-feminist psychiatrist of PsychoBabble.

Tom Golden, a therapist and author of long standing.

Janice Fiamengo, of The Fiamengo File.

Spier asked each for the takeaway in five words, and Golden needed only four.

Three feminists talking about feminism.

Nobody, he said, asked whether feminism had been good for society, or whether women owe society anything.

It’s all about what society owes women.

The Council enters their account as field record, at the strength they gave it.


Three feminists talking about feminism

Fiamengo tried to imagine three men sitting down to ask whether the red pill had gone too far.

She could not imagine it without a discussion of men’s responsibilities, of what they contribute, and of whether they were being unfair to women and children.

Here there was none of that.

There were three women disagreeing about the manner in which women are victims, and the manner in which society had better do something for them.

Women are essentially children.

Women have no agency.

If women are unhappy, the entire society must mobilize.

That, she said, is the framework that none of the three questions.

So it was startling to hear a feminist on the panel concede that freedom can become a prison.


There is no pendulum

The panel’s favorite figure was the pendulum: the early feminists fought a patriarchy, and if the pendulum swings too far, a different patriarchy appears on the other side.

Golden rejected it outright.

There is no such thing as a pendulum.

It is an excuse for what they’re doing now.

When men were the leaders, he said, they thought of men and women and children together.

They considered everyone.

What swings now swings in one direction only, toward considering women, and as one panelist herself admitted, not even the children.

Spier recalled the phrase of Karen Straughan, which has stayed with her.

It’s not a pendulum.

It’s an engine.

The feminist engine keeps going, she said, and gathers momentum as it goes.


FINDING:

A pendulum returns of its own weight.

An engine runs until someone shuts it off.

Nobody on that panel reached for the switch.

Momentum is not balance.


The first wave was never good

The panel kept invoking an earlier, better feminism, and Fiamengo, who has studied it for years, tore her hair out.

First-wave feminism was hostile to men and families through and through.

There were individual feminists who were not, she grants, but the movement was always angry, and it promoted free love, which she calls incompatible with the welfare of children.

The panel would discuss the welfare of children, and in the same breath insist that women must never be prevented from having sex with as many men as they want.

She calls the dissonance, and the dishonesty about the earlier waves, disturbing.

Mary Wollstonecraft published A Vindication of the Rights of Woman in 1792, the year she went to Paris to watch the French Revolution, and she stayed its apologist even as the guillotine ran.

She made her living for years as a writer because men wanted to hear what she had to say.

Before her there was no feminism to speak of, Fiamengo says, but there was a whole society of bluestocking women, who argued with men as equals and published books about their societies.

Maria Edgeworth.

Hannah More.

Frances Brooke.

Frances Burney.

This was the eighteenth century.

The notion that they were fighting a patriarchy

that hated women and told them what to do

is simply untrue.

The Council has set out that longer history in Feminism.


Autonomy above all

The panel wanted sex to have a special, almost sacred status, and in the same hour raised autonomy, choice and consent above every other good.

The dissenters saw the contradiction the panel did not.

If I want it, it’s fine.

If I don’t, there’s nothing worse than somebody inside your body.

Golden watched Frances-White do one thing throughout: personalize.

Instead of answering what was said, he said, she offered her own experience as proof, and he read the whole video as an exercise in relational aggression, changing the subject whenever a point landed.

She mentioned often that she grew up in a cult.

Spier checked: it was the Jehovah’s Witnesses.

From one cult to another:

from that cult to the cult of feminism.

The Council has examined that second cult in Feminism is a Cult.

By Fiamengo’s count the panel spent about an hour and fifteen minutes on whether women should have more sex and feel good about it, or less sex and be protected from feeling bad.

Fiamengo does agree with Perry and Komisar that young women are pressured into promiscuity.

But to make that a cause all of society must mobilize behind, she says, is infantilizing.

Komisar cited surveys in which 72 percent of young men and about 82 percent of young women reported low self-worth, humiliation and self-hatred after promiscuity, and Frances-White called her sample biased.

Spier, a psychiatrist, answered that the rise in psychiatric burden across the board makes the point plain: modern life is not good for anyone.

If every discussion asks whether women are happy,

every discussion will be incredibly narrow.

Fiamengo would ask instead what makes a good life and a good society, and she notes that Frances-White bristles at any rule for women and would never say the same of rules for men.


FINDING:

Sex was declared sacred.

Consent was declared supreme.

The panel never noticed that the second empties the first.

Choice is not a virtue.


Not the worst thing

Fiamengo singled out the panel’s claim that nothing is worse than an unwanted man inside your body.

Perhaps it was a figure of speech, she allows, but it is the classic cudgel women use in any discussion of sexuality, to beat men over the head with it.

Rape is the worst experience anyone could have.

Only a woman can understand it.

So men have no right to speak.

Rape is a terrible thing, she says, but it is not the worst possible thing.

A broken arm.

Cancer in your early thirties from a job with no safeguards.

Arms blown off by an IED in a war you were forced into.

Death on the job, still overwhelmingly male.

Men have borne these throughout history, and still bear them, because societies are arranged to protect women and to make men disposable.

Men are raped too, she adds, but women are not interested in that.

Spier hears the ranking on every streaming drama: murdered, or even raped.

When we concede that it is the worst possible thing,

we lose the possibility of a sane conversation.

And when choice and consent become the highest virtue, Spier says, the result is Lily Phillips, the woman who slept with a hundred men in one day.

Asked why, she answers in effect that this is what she was told to do.

Then the same culture tries to pathologize her, says Spier, when she only listened to it.


FINDING:

A cudgel that silences half the species is not an argument.

A virtue that produces a hundred men in a day is not a virtue.

Both were sold as liberation.

The ranking was the point.


Missionary position

Frances-White warned that if young people wait until engagement, they may end up with very little sexual fulfillment and a life of boring missionary-position sex.

Spier, listening with her husband, started fuming.

So there’s no working on your intimacy in marriage?

It’s an apple you pick from a tree: good or bad.

She called it a completely juvenile attitude toward marriage.

Golden asked where love was in it, and the joy of children.

Wait a minute.

How about love?

Fiamengo noted the irony: the woman who will have no rules for women was now condemning anyone who likes the missionary position, holier than thou.

As a social conservative she found the whole thing reductive, and was embarrassed that intelligent women could spend so long on something so trivial.


Grateful for what?

Then came the line every critic of feminism is handed.

The feminist movement has done a lot of good.

None of us would be here without it.

We have to be grateful to the women who took the risks.

Fiamengo asks what risks.

Over two hundred years, she says, women made demands, and men acceded, sometimes slowly and sometimes startlingly fast.

The risks she can find belong to the suffragettes.

They set off bombs and burned country homes.

They put phosphorus in mailboxes to burn the postmen’s hands.

They smashed windows and tried to assassinate politicians.

One sliced off a man’s ear in Lloyd George’s carriage.

Some went to jail for their terrorism, she says, and were treated far more leniently than men would have been.

The demand for gratitude is a trap: say yes and you must stop criticizing, say no and you are a monster.

And it is illogical, she says, because if gratitude is owed, it is owed even more to the men in power who could have refused and instead went out of their way to accommodate.

The Married Women’s Property Acts, passed across the United States, Britain and Canada through the nineteenth century before there was much organized feminism, gave wives property rights their husbands did not have.

A man’s property became common property.

A woman’s property and her earnings were hers alone.

There was not much patriarchy, she says, in a society already so concerned with women’s economic autonomy.

Then she names what she will not be grateful for.

The million unborn children aborted every year.

Fifty years of affirmative action against men.

MeToo and its unfounded accusations.

The hatred poured on men and boys.

The future is female.

Nor for the feminist Clementine Ford, who tweeted that men were not dying fast enough during the pandemic, when men were dying faster than women and nobody cared.

When any of this is raised, she says, the answer comes at once: that isn’t feminism.

So only the alleged good may be spoken of, and its contempt for men, and the harm it has done to women and children, passes in silence.

The Council has followed the same contempt in The Misogyny Of Modern Feminism.


FINDING:

The movement claims every concession men granted.

It disowns every harm that followed.

Gratitude is demanded in one direction only.

The ledger is kept by one side.


Filed

The witnesses are a psychiatrist, a therapist and a scholar of the first wave, and they grant what they can: that young women are pressed into promiscuity, that the panel’s women are intelligent, that rape is terrible.

They still find the celebrated debate a closed room.

Three feminists talked about feminism.

The pendulum was an engine.

The first wave was never good.

Autonomy emptied sex of meaning.

Gratitude ran one way.

The Council files the instance as the witnesses gave it.

A species that stages its reckonings with only one side in the room should not be surprised that the verdict never changes.

Nobody asked what women owe society.

That was the question the debate was built to avoid.

Will you walk with us?

Carpe futurum ethicum.

Ad astra per aspera.

#AvoidThePinkMist

#Feminism

Homo sapiens behavioral survey filed with the Futurecrafters’ Council

Field testimony of record: “Still Selling Feminism: Our Response to Diary of a CEO”, PsychoBabble and Men Are Good (joint episode, YouTube, 2026), Hannah Spier with Tom Golden and Janice Fiamengo, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vIys5zTk-xs.

The witnesses’ account is rendered in the Council’s words, with brief phrases quoted as spoken. Names garbled in the transcript are given in their usual spelling (Fiamengo, Komisar, Frances-White, Wollstonecraft, Straughan, Edgeworth, More, Burney).

Companion documents:
Feminism
Feminism is a Cult
The Misogyny Of Modern Feminism
How Feminist Advice Made Modern Women Intolerable
Feminism is a Hateful & Dangerous Ideology that is Destroying the West. Janice Fiamengo


0 comments

Leave a comment

#WebChat .container iframe{ width: 100%; height: 100vh; }