The Futurecrafters’ Council · A Xenological Survey of Sol-3
An evolutionary psychologist tells a physician that the ideology unmaking the West is a selection event, and that its cleverest converts joined because the clever conform
❖
In September 2025 Dr. Hannah Spier, a physician who hosts the show Psychobabble on her channel, released a conversation with Edward Dutton.
Dutton is a British anthropologist turned evolutionary psychologist, a professor in Poland who lives in northern Finland and runs the channel The Jolly Heretic.
His case is that the species spent its whole history under a harsh sieve, took the sieve away around 1800, and has been decaying in body and mind ever since.
Then something odd arrived to finish the job: wokeness.
Wokeness is not the disease. It is the selection event.
It persuades the unfit not to breed,
and only the religious and the conservative refuse it.
The Council enters his account as field record, at the strength he gave it.
The women at the hotel gates
Spier opens on the scenes in Britain that made her release the interview: women arrested for holding placards that invited the police to arrest them.
Dutton describes the counter-demonstrations at the hotels where the government has housed illegal migrants, almost always young men from the Middle East, in rural towns.
At best, he says, the men sit in parks watching the local children; at worst there have been rapes and attempted rapes.
When the locals protest, a crowd arrives calling itself Stand Up to Racism to shout that the townspeople are racists and Nazis.
It is mainly women, he says: young, middle-class women.
The brightly colored hair, the tattoos,
the general screaming and unhappiness.
Any cause will serve, Palestine one month and the migrant hotels the next, so long as it lets them feel morally righteous and show it.
What is new is the reaction: in one town a hostile crowd literally chased them out, and they stood stunned, because virtue signaling had never before cost them anything.
Spier asks whether that is secretly what they want, since there is an element of masochism in it, and Dutton grants it very possibly is.
The Council watched the same crowd form in The Reason Women Are SO Susceptible to Groupthink, where the fear of exclusion and the hunger to belong were found to run the species’ female herd; Dutton now asks where the herd’s ideas come from.
Forty percent of the children
Dutton began in theology and fundamentalist sects, and moved to Finland, where he found the Finns quite unlike the Norwegians they were supposed to resemble.
The humanities could not say why, and he came to see that nobody he had been taught by was talking about genetics.
In that light, he says, everything opened up, and he has worked from it ever since.
Until about 1800 the species lived under harsh Darwinian selection, with something like forty percent of its children dying.
In Finland in 1698, half the population died in a single famine.
Under that pressure a fitness factor was selected for, and ancient genomes let it be tracked.
Intelligence, physical health and religiosity rose together.
Religiosity, Dutton says, has every component of an adaptation: a cognitive bias that switches on under stress, bound to being pro-social, group-oriented and fertile.
It is tied genetically to mental and physical health, and stimulating the brain’s frontal cortex with magnets makes a person both more religious and more ethnocentric.
Then the Industrial Revolution came, and child mortality fell from thirty-five or forty percent to one percent.
The sieve was gone, and the mutations began to pile up.
What was being selected against now survives, and he speaks of a crumbling genome.
Carried on forever, it leaves a species so unfit that when its civilization falls, or a meteorite strikes, everyone on the grid is destroyed.
Only the remote islanders would be left,
and they would remember us as gods.
FINDING:
The species was sifted hard for intelligence, health and faith.
Comfort removed the sieve two centuries ago.
Its genome has been crumbling since.
Something had to click in.
Getting stupider
Spier objects: are people not getting smarter, with better nutrition?
No, Dutton says, and he draws intelligence as a pyramid.
At its base sit narrow abilities such as catching a ball or spotting patterns; above them verbal, mathematical and spatial ability; at the top, general intelligence, g.
Since about 1930 every cohort has scored higher on IQ tests, but only on the base of the pyramid, above all pattern spotting, and not on g.
That is an IQ rise, he says. It is not an intelligence rise.
A more scientific society trained its people to think scientifically, until they reached their phenotypic maximum on those narrow skills.
Nutrition plays little part: the Dutch who starved in the Second World War did not raise a duller generation.
Intelligence is low in heritability in childhood, when parents and teachers build the environment, and high in adulthood, when people build their own to match their innate ability.
Once the narrow skills peaked, the real decline showed: in Finland, from the cohort born in 1980, scores began to fall.
Reaction times have lengthened since 1880, consistent with a loss of about fifteen IQ points.
In Iceland, across three generations, the variants associated with educational attainment have become rarer.
We are losing about one point a decade. We are getting stupider.
Why the clever believe it
Then comes the answer to the title, and it is short.
Intelligence, Dutton says, is a little different from the rest of the fitness factor, because it is associated with social conformity.
In a left-wing society intelligent people will tend to be left-wing.
In a right-wing society they will be right-wing.
The clever read the wind faster than anyone, and the wind has been blowing one way since the 1960s.
He reduces the left-right divide to five moral foundations, three for a pack species and two for climbing the pack.
In-group loyalty, obedience to authority, sanctity against disgust.
Equality and the avoidance of harm.
Right-wing people weigh all five about equally; left-wing people care only for the two individual ones.
That fits, he says, because they are high in mental and physical illness, and so they are like girls: they play for status covertly, by virtue signaling.
Among Europeans, once the rising way of life reaches about twenty percent it looks like the future, and people flip to it very quickly.
In England and America the flip to individualism came in the 1960s, the intelligent followed it, and it ran away.
Runaway concern with equality and with harm,
until no one may tell a man that he is a man.
The Council traced that turn from masculine to feminine norms, institution by institution, in The GREAT FEMINIZATION: The Real Reason Everything Went Woke; Dutton supplies the biology beneath it.
FINDING:
The clever conform faster than anyone.
Since the 1960s the conformity has run one way.
Their intelligence carried them into it.
That is why intelligent people believe it.
The death cult
By the left, Dutton means being left-wing and atheist, and he says both are associated with mental illness, physical illness and markers of mutation.
Left-wing men are shorter; left-wing women are less symmetrical in the face; left-wing people are less likely to recover from cancer and carry more genetic disease.
Spier asks whether the faces are a matter of hygiene and feminist fashion, and he says no: a Danish study and its replications measured the symmetry of the face.
The Council heard this show’s question, what the left’s narratives do to the mind, in What Man-Hating Does to Your Mental Health, where contempt was found to deform the women who held it.
Here is Dutton's engine: a genetically sickening population inherits a culture built when it was healthy, telling boys to be boys and girls to have children.
Once the flip comes, the culture turns over, and the road map it hands children becomes maladaptive.
Be gay, be trans, be guilty for being white, for being a man, for being human.
Go on climate strike in your most fertile years, and do not have babies.
Be proud to be fat and unhealthy. Abort your offspring. Euthanize yourself.
Choose a high material life over children, and welcome mass immigration.
Most people, unhealthy and genetically inclined a little to the left, will be sucked into what he calls this death cult and will not pass on their genes.
Two kinds will resist it: the stupid, who simply have babies,
and, among the intelligent, the religious and the conservative.
Intelligence is about eighty percent genetic; once it is controlled for, the great predictors of fertility are conservatism, fifty or sixty percent genetic, and religiosity, up to seventy percent.
The resisters become the surviving population.
The population renders itself healthy again.
The Council found the same ideology waiting itself out in Feminism Is a Deathtrap for Society, and the empty cradles of The Birthrate Collapse is a Prisoner's Dilemma; Dutton names who fills the next generation.
FINDING:
A sick population inherited a healthy culture.
It flipped the culture into a road map against life.
Those who follow it leave no heirs.
The death cult selects its own survivors.
Neo-Byzantiums
There is more, Dutton says: the left pushes for the collapse of the very society that shelters it.
Encouraging intelligent women to suppress their fertility while welfare helps the least able have children forces down the intelligence of society.
They are collapsing society back to a harsher level,
under which people like them will die.
Rome did not vanish, he says; it shrank, and held out in a diminished form at Byzantium.
He expects the same: islands of reasonably intelligent, ethnocentric, religious people, with chaos, war and death around them.
He does not call it a good thing; it will be like Norway’s fundamentalist enclaves, and it will not be fun.
Spier, just back from such a town, found it rather nice, pro-Israel and warm to her son in his kippah.
Wokeness, Dutton says, accelerates all of it: by making anyone remotely conservative feel like an outcast and scum, it drives them to find one another.
With the internet they form para-societies and a paracademia, and they marry and have children with people who share their views.
Spier objects that the left controls academia, and he answers with Victorian England, where the Anglican universities did not do the important work.
Oxygen was found at a dissenting academy.
Darwin and Galton were gentleman scholars.
The genius type, he says, a high-intelligence sub-psychopath who cannot get on in the girl world of academia, will go outside it, and Substack now lets people fund such scholars.
The Council heard a nearer cause of the same decline in How Female Power Caused The Decline Of The West; Dutton sets it inside the genome’s long account.
Wokeness accelerates the breakup while we are still healthy enough.
And it must happen, he says, before the West is completely taken over by Islam.
FINDING:
The woke make outcasts of the fit.
The outcasts find each other and build outside.
The break comes while they can still build.
The decline is also the escape.
Filed
The witness speaks as a scientist of fitness, not a partisan, and he grants what a hostile reader would not expect: the enclaves he predicts will not be fun, and he does not call them good.
He even grants nuance and variation in the global data, and holds to the trend.
Forty percent of the children, then one percent.
One point a decade, and a culture turned against life.
The Council files the instance as the witness gave it.
A species freed from the sieve grew sick, and its cleverest members, being conformists, carried the sickness into an ideology that tells them not to breed.
The ideology sorts the species,
and those who refuse it inherit what is left.
Will you walk with us?
Carpe futurum ethicum.
Ad astra per aspera.
#AvoidThePinkMist
#Wokeness
Homo sapiens behavioral survey filed with the Futurecrafters’ Council
Field testimony of record: “Why Intelligent People Believe Destructive Ideas | Edward Dutton”, Hannah Spier, MD (Psychobabble, YouTube, 2025), https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QnVWb4mwcvo.
The witness’s account is rendered in the Council’s words, with brief phrases quoted as spoken.
Companion documents:
The Reason Women Are SO Susceptible to Groupthink
The GREAT FEMINIZATION: The Real Reason Everything Went Woke
What Man-Hating Does to Your Mental Health
Feminism Is a Deathtrap for Society
The Birthrate Collapse is a Prisoner's Dilemma
How Female Power Caused The Decline Of The West
Align to the Mind: Strong Minds vs. Mind Viruses
Hoe_Math Level 1: Introduction
Hoe_Math LEVELS OF THINKING (Basic Version)
Astra Blue – P Doom (Official Music Video)
Astra Blue - Bullish on Extinction (Official Music Video)
Astra Blue - The App Says Wait (Official Music Video)