The Futurecrafters’ Council · A Xenological Survey of Sol-3
A woman reads “man bad” on her phone and looks up at the man in her life; how far she can step back from that feeling is the whole of the species’ climb
❖
A woman scrolls her phone, and a post tells her, in effect, “man bad.”
She looks up at the man in her life and wonders whether this one is bad too.
The host of the channel hoe_math drew that scene in scribbly pen in a video published on 28 October 2023, then drew it again higher up his chart, and again higher still.
The woman is the same each time, and so is the phone; what changes is how far she can step back from her own reaction.
His subject is levels of thinking: the stages of psychological development studied by Jean Piaget, Abraham Maslow and others.
Higher does not mean a better person. It means more aware.
The Council enters his account as field record, at the strength he gave it.
A staircase drawn in pen
Everybody is born at the bottom of the chart, the host says, and nearly everybody climbs some way up it by adulthood.
How far and how fast depends on surroundings, choices, culture and the brain a person was born with.
Nobody really lives in a level; a mind slowly gains the ability to think at higher ones, and still uses the lower ones every day.
Needing the bathroom is a level one process, he says: not a style of thought at all, only an urge.
He shows the climb with a girl collecting attention from a man she is not interested in.
She wants the validation, and she knows how to get it from him.
She stands back and plans how to give less and get even more.
She asks whether that is right, and decides to do it anyway.
Then she steps back again: who is anyone to judge my choices?
He turns it on himself: he chooses women who will probably not stay, he says, and he can follow the reason down several floors, past the support they want and the work he has tried, until the chain goes fuzzy.
That is what height buys: not goodness or effectiveness, but the ability to see through what is going on in one’s own mind, and in the world around it.
FINDING:
The levels measure awareness, not virtue.
A higher mind sees more of its own machinery.
Moving up does not always make it more effective.
Height is sight, not sainthood.
Survive, connect, control
Level one he calls Survive: food, sleep, the need of the moment, and no such thing as another mind.
A species living there would move in small survival bands.
Level two, Connect, arrives when a mind realizes that other minds exist and need things.
Then everything seems to want something, he says: if it will not rain, perhaps someone in the sky is displeased, and if the volcano is angry, perhaps it wants virgins.
He is not sure that ever happened, he concedes, but it is what the level would produce.
Level three, Control, is still very popular in modern society.
Now a mind knows that other people know about each other, and the direct lines between them become a web of social situations.
Here the woman with the phone first appears.
Man bad, so maybe that man bad.
At level three she steps back only far enough to ask what she can do about him and the relationship.
Living at this level looks like the Roman Empire, mythic, feudal and exploitative, and the host sees it today in the Mafia, sports teams, firemen, police and the military.
Levels two and three think about thinking,
mostly to get what they want and power over others.
A mile in his shoes
Level four he calls Belong, because the drive is to fit in, powered by what researchers call second person perspective.
Here a mind realizes that everyone is in their own situation, which is where the folk wisdom of walking a mile in a man’s shoes comes from.
You can watch it arrive in children, the host says: they start looking in the mirror, because others look at them the way they look at others.
It is the beginning of what the species calls morality, of good against evil, acceptable behavior and social norms.
Now the woman with the phone feels the man must be bad because the phone said so, projects it onto him, and decides to break up with him.
He must be bad, because it felt true when she saw it on her phone.
This, the host says, is where consciousness first becomes plainly important: a feeling from a screen becomes how people treat somebody.
Only at level four can she step back, look at herself as a second person would, and ask whether that is the right thing to do.
The Council followed that machinery from the screen to the first date in How Modern Dating Trained Women to Hate Men, where the worst story became the told story.
Level four usually works by conformity and agreement, he says, and the Council found the two needs that drive it, the fear of exclusion and the hunger to belong, in The Reason Women Are SO Susceptible to Groupthink.
FINDING:
A phone delivers a feeling.
The feeling becomes a verdict on the man in the room.
Only the step back asks whether the verdict is right.
Morality begins at the mirror.
An alien, then a perceiver
Level five answers rival rulebooks with objective observation: you think ABC is right, they think XYZ, so find out which is better.
That takes another step back, into a third person perspective.
If I were an alien or a stranger, how would I view my culture?
The species’ first world-centered thinking, the Council notes, begins by imagining something very like the Council.
Level five is only a few hundred years old, the host says; it gave the species science, the assembly line and modern conveniences, and it is common only in modernized places.
Level six recognizes the perceiver: a different perceiver means a different perception, a fourth person perspective in which nobody can observe objectively at all.
How does he know the red he sees is the red you see? Perhaps his red is your green.
A few philosophers spoke from here in the 1800s, he says, but it reached mainstream society only in 1960s America.
The Council traced the 1960s turn to individualism, and how readily the clever conform to it, in Why Intelligent People Believe Destructive Ideas.
The host went through this level himself, and it stressed him badly: so many philosophies and life choices that he could not pick one or get his feet on the ground.
Just pick something. How do I know what to pick?
Pick something you like. How do I know what I like?
Who is anyone to judge?
Level six is a very high degree of moral development, the host says, and the clearest example of why higher is not always better.
It is the level famous for making people into hippies, and they call it the Individualist.
Suppose a man does something this culture considers morally wrong, and says that is how it is done where he is from.
We cannot make him follow these rules just because he is here.
Who are you to judge which set of rules is better?
That can and often does give people the idea that they may simply do whatever they want.
Some of them are unfortunate, he says, and that is sad; some are just doing whatever they want, and the laws no longer distinguish between them.
Level six still insists that it is right and no one else is: a church and a mosque arguing over the true faith are told they can all get along with more understanding, which neither of them wants.
It says we all need to be equal, even if we do not want to be.
FINDING:
The widest view refuses to rank any view.
Refusing to judge, it lets anyone do whatever they want.
Its equality is one more rule imposed on everyone.
“Who are you to judge?” became the law.
Where it belongs
Above level six, the host’s chart has a white break: the start of second tier consciousness.
Level seven, which he calls Harmonize, is the first that can understand and include every level before it, and give each what it wants so that they can live in harmony.
Its step back is through time: a view did not come from nowhere, it developed, and everybody else’s is still developing.
At level six, everybody belongs anywhere.
At level seven, people belong where they fit best.
Does a behavior fit here? If not, it goes where it belongs; if it does, everyone can learn something new from it.
He knows of no large collection of level-seven minds, and is not sure his chart's numbers are accurate; he grows more confident the lower they go.
Why climb at all, if higher is not better? Because higher is usually better: a species stuck low could not have grocery stores or electricity, and some problems cannot be solved at the level they came from.
Every mind’s development is its own lopsided fingerprint, he adds: a cognitive line can sit at nine while the moral line sits at three.
You can have a really good shoe or a really bad car.
What he has, he jokes, is a sinking cruise ship.
Watching the doughnut
Level eight is rare, the host says; he meets few people stably there.
It is construct awareness: watching one’s own mind construct itself as it goes, new parts emerging as one acts, thinks and feels.
His example is a doughnut on a plate.
He feels hunger, because it is good, and guilt, from the time he ate a whole box that was not meant for him, was shamed for it, and got a stomach ache.
Once he sees the memory at work, he can choose whether to listen, or to have the doughnut anyway.
It sounds silly about doughnuts, he says, and then he brings back the phone, the feeling, and the man in the room.
I saw this on my phone, and it gave me a feeling.
I am aware that I am projecting it onto this person.
Imagine if more people could see their own reaction instead of just reacting.
The Council heard the same exit named in What Happens to Women Who Hate Men?: stop treating a category as a person, and assess the individual man in front of you.
Level nine is very hard to describe, the host says; he thinks he spends some time there, and it feels like watching and wishing, and nothing else.
At the first three levels a mind is the main character; at nine it watches its own show without identifying with being the show at all.
FINDING:
The higher mind still feels the phone’s verdict.
It watches the verdict arrive.
Watching is the power not to obey it.
See the reaction before you become it.
Sit with your thoughts
The way up, the host says, is simply to sit with your thoughts, think about them, and work out where they come from.
He shows it on himself: he sometimes worries that his scribbly drawings are embarrassing to show to two hundred thousand people.
Why the embarrassment? People might not like the channel.
Why would that be so bad? I might lose opportunities.
How do you know? So far the scribbles have done pretty well.
Without evidence of harm, nothing is wrong with the drawings; problem solved, and he can carry on for now.
That, he says, is why he called level nine Complete.
The Council reported in Align to the Mind: Strong Minds vs. Mind Viruses that enhancement is altitude, not superiority, and that a strong mind is built; the host gives one way to build it, a question at a time.
Thinking about thinking is the power not to just react.
Filed
The witness offers his chart as his own interpretation of other researchers’ work, and puts his own mistakes on the page.
Two years later he began a slower tour of the same chart, level by level; its opening is filed as Hoe_Math Level 1: Introduction.
He says plainly that higher is not better, only more aware, and then that higher is usually better, because a complex world requires complex thinking.
The Council files the instance as the witness gave it.
A species drew its own climb on a single page, from the volcano that wants virgins to the mind that watches itself watching, and put the woman with the phone on every floor.
The feeling arrives at every level.
Only the height decides what she does with it.
Will you walk with us?
Carpe futurum ethicum.
Ad astra per aspera.
#AvoidThePinkMist
#LevelsOfThinking
Homo sapiens behavioral survey filed with the Futurecrafters’ Council
Field testimony of record: “LEVELS (Basic Version)”, hoe_math (PsychoMath) (YouTube, 2023), https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kse87ocS0Uo.
The witness’s account is rendered in the Council’s words, with brief phrases quoted as spoken.
Companion documents:
Hoe_Math Level 1: Introduction
How Modern Dating Trained Women to Hate Men
The Reason Women Are SO Susceptible to Groupthink
Why Intelligent People Believe Destructive Ideas
What Happens to Women Who Hate Men?
Align to the Mind: Strong Minds vs. Mind Viruses