Thomas Sowell - The Reality Of Multiculturalism

Multiculturalism, while promoting diversity and acceptance, has led to polarization, academic struggles for black students, and a decline in the quality of education, and individuals must navigate their circumstances regardless of historical injustices.

Questions to inspire discussion

• What is the speaker's opinion on the benefits of diversity in admissions decisions?

  —The speaker discusses the lack of evidence for the benefits of diversity in admissions decisions, citing the Supreme Court case Gruder versus Bollinger.

• What challenges do black students face in elite institutions?

  —Black students at elite institutions like Cornell and MIT struggled academically despite high SAT scores, highlighting the challenges of multiculturalism in education.

• Who does the speaker blame for perpetuating racism?

  —The speaker blames progressives, liberals, and multiculturalists for perpetuating racism and creating a culture that worsens the situation.

• What impact does the absence of a black subculture in Germany have on African Americans?

  —The absence of a black subculture in Germany allowed the children of black American soldiers to grow up with the same expectations and culture as white children, leading to no IQ differences, highlighting the impact of black subculture in America on African Americans.

• What role do culture and geography play in societal advancement for black kids?

  —The material standard of living for black kids today is higher than in the past, but the quality of education has declined, and factors such as culture and geography play a role in societal advancement.

Key Insights

• 🌍 Multiculturalism insists that less fortunate groups are not to be blamed for disparities, but society needs to accept them as they are.
• 📚 "A growing body of empirical data shows that black students mismatched with the colleges or universities they attend fail or drop out more often than other students."
• 📚 Thomas Sowell highlights the academic struggles of black students at elite institutions, despite their high SAT scores.
• 🤔 There is no such test for most intellectuals is whether other intellectuals go along with them and if they all have a wrong idea then it becomes invincible.
• 🧠 The absence of black subculture in Germany allowed black and white children to show no IQ differences, highlighting the impact of culture on development.

#Philosophy #ThomasSowell #Multiculturalism 

Professor Sowell offers his insights and studied opinion on issues of diversity, culture and social justice.  

 Clips 

• 00:00 📚 Multiculturalism insists that disparities in income, education, and crime rates among less fortunate groups are not their fault and society needs to accept them as they are.
• 01:09 🗣 Multiculturalism in language studies has its own validity, but certain speech patterns can hold people back from participating in wider societies, and the origins of these patterns can be traced back to specific regions.
• 02:26 🤔 Multiculturalism is promoted without evidence, and diverse societies struggle to avoid conflict.
• 03:53 📚 Multiculturalism policies have led to polarization and mismatched black students in higher education, with no evidence for the benefits of diversity in admissions decisions.
  • The speaker discusses the Supreme Court case Gruder versus Bollinger and the lack of evidence for the benefits of diversity in admissions decisions.
  • Multiculturalism policies have led to greater polarization and mismatched black students in colleges and universities.
• 05:59 📚 Black students at elite institutions struggle academically despite high SAT scores, highlighting the challenges of multiculturalism in education, with progressives, liberals, and multiculturalists perpetuating racism and creating a worsening culture.
  • Black students at elite institutions like Cornell and MIT struggled academically despite high SAT scores, highlighting the challenges of multiculturalism in education.
  • Progressives, liberals, and multiculturalists are all at fault for perpetuating racism and creating a culture that worsens the situation.
• 07:59 💡 Intellectuals often come up with wrong ideas without consequences, leading to limited thinking and influence, while experts in different academic departments may believe the same things without studying or working on related policies.
  • Intellectuals often come up with wrong ideas and pay no price for it, leading to limited thinking and influence.
  • Experts in different academic departments may not have studied or done work on policies like affirmative action, yet they all seem to believe the same things about it.
• 09:31 🤔 Despite historical injustices, society cannot be automatically blamed or relied upon to fix disparities, and individuals must navigate their circumstances regardless.
• 11:16 📚 The quality of education has declined for black kids, culture and geography play a role in societal advancement, and the impact of black subculture in America on African Americans is significant.
  • The material standard of living for black kids today is higher than in the past, but the quality of education has declined, and factors such as culture and geography play a role in societal advancement.
  • The absence of a black subculture in Germany allowed the children of black American soldiers to grow up with the same expectations and culture as white children, leading to no IQ differences, highlighting the impact of black subculture in America on African Americans.
  • The subculture in the South held back both whites and blacks, as evidenced by lower test scores, and it would be ideal for intellectuals to address this issue.

 0:15:1 2023-06-25T13:52:03Z