Plato's Apology of Socrates Explained

Socrates sees himself as a gadfly, challenging and improving society, even if it's unpleasant 

Questions to inspire discussion

• What is Plato's Apology?

  —Plato's Apology is a reconstruction of Socrates' defense speech at his trial, written by Plato after Socrates' death, and is likely to be historically accurate.

• What are the formal charges against Socrates?

  —Socrates is accused of impiety, corrupting the youth, and not believing in the gods of the state.

• Why is Socrates considered a gadfly?

  —Socrates sees himself as a gadfly, necessary to stir the city of Athens into action and improvement, even if it's unpleasant.

• What is Socrates' attitude towards his accusers?

  —Socrates acknowledges the persuasive words of his accusers, recognizes their rhetorical framing, and addresses his reputation and age in the trial.

• What is the outcome of Socrates' trial?

  —Socrates is found guilty and sentenced to death by the jury. 

Key Insights

• 🤯 Socrates sets out on a mission to find a man wiser than himself, in order to challenge the Oracle's proclamation.
• 🤔 Socrates found that those with the most reputation for wisdom were actually the most foolish, leading to distress in an accomplished nation like Athens.
• 🤔 Socrates' challenges and alternatives to traditional religious views made him enemies, portraying him as an enemy of religion.
• 🤔 The charge against Socrates is that he does not believe in the gods of the city but has his own divinities, leading to accusations of impiety.
• 🛡️ Socrates emphasizes the importance of courage in both physical and intellectual battles, highlighting the need for philosophers to be courageous in the pursuit of truth and virtue.
• 🐎 Socrates compares himself to a gadfly, irritating the complacent city of Athens to spur it into action and reaction.
• 🦟 Socrates sees himself as a gadfly, challenging and improving society, even if it's unpleasant.
• 💭 Socrates argues that a society that does not welcome and prize philosophers cannot be healthy, as they push and prod us to do the hard work of critical thinking and self-reflection.

#StephenHicks #Philosophy #Plato #Socrates  

Clips 

• 00:00 📜 Socrates defends himself in Plato's Apology, acknowledging his accusers' persuasive words, emphasizing his age and lack of previous court appearances, and addressing the formal charges brought against him.
  • Plato's Apology is a reconstruction of Socrates' defense speech at his trial, written by Plato after Socrates' death, and is likely to be historically accurate.
  • Stefanus numbers in Plato's works indicate where to find specific passages in different translations and editions.
  • Socrates is about to give his defense speech in a democratically conducted trial in Athens.
  • Socrates acknowledges the persuasive words of his accusers, recognizes their rhetorical framing, and addresses his reputation and age in the trial.
  • Socrates, in his defense, emphasizes his age and the fact that he has never appeared in court before, implying that he has conducted himself honorably and justly.
  • Socrates addresses the formal charges brought by three accusers and discusses the difficulty of addressing biases and rumors spread by personal enemies and grudges.
• 08:19 🧐 Socrates is perceived as a sophist but denies it, facing ridicule and opposition for his teaching methods and beliefs, yet is recognized as wise by the Oracle at Delphi.
  • Socrates is seen as a wise man who has a reputation for using sneaky tactics to make bad arguments seem better and undermine good arguments, and is associated with the sophists who were paid teachers of rhetoric in Athens.
  • Socrates is concerned with countering the perception that he is a sophist, emphasizing that he does not charge money and does not believe in skepticism, relativism, and power politics like the sophists.
  • Aristophanes ridiculed Socrates in his plays, portraying him as a ridiculous philosopher and a paid sophist.
  • Socrates is seen as argumentative, corrupts students, sacrilegious, and dangerous by those who disagree with his teaching methods and traditional beliefs.
  • Socrates' reputation and wisdom are based on the recognition and endorsement of the god Apollo through the Oracle at Delphi.
  • Socrates was considered the wisest man by the Oracle, despite not considering himself a philosophical genius.
• 14:51 🧐 Socrates challenges the Oracle's proclamation of his wisdom, seeks out wiser men, and concludes that true wisdom is knowing one's own ignorance.
  • Socrates does not believe he possesses wisdom and has dedicated his life to seeking wisdom in philosophy.
  • Socrates questions the Oracle's statement that he is the wisest man in Athens, and decides to find a man wiser than himself to challenge the Oracle's proclamation.
  • Socrates challenges a politician's wisdom, revealing that he is not as wise as he believes himself to be.
  • Socrates found that those with the most reputation for wisdom were not actually wise, leading to enmity and a lawsuit against him.
  • Socrates is accused of impiety and challenging traditional religious beliefs, but he concludes that true wisdom is knowing that one's wisdom is worth nothing.
  • Socrates believes he is wiser than those who falsely claim to have wisdom because he knows he has none.
• 24:42 🧐 Socrates defends himself against charges of impiety, claiming his pursuit of wisdom is a divine mission, leading to his poverty and accusations by his enemies, who wanted to get rid of him for puncturing their pretensions to wisdom.
  • Socrates defends himself against charges of impiety by claiming that his pursuit of wisdom is a divine mission, leading to his poverty and the accusations against him by Mellitus, Anitus, and Lycon.
  • Socrates' enemies wanted to get rid of him because he punctured their pretensions to wisdom, and the formal charges against him were not about truth or justice, but about getting rid of enemies.
  • Socrates is accused of corrupting the youth and not believing in the gods of the state, teaching them false religion and undermining the future of Athens.
  • Socrates cross-examines his prosecutor Melatus about the improvement of the youth and challenges him to identify their improver.
  • Socrates challenges Mellitus to identify people who can properly educate the youth, highlighting the difficulty of doing so in front of a large jury.
• 30:31 🧐 Socrates questions Melitus's expertise and motives, clarifies his belief in different gods, and argues that his accuser is motivated by envy and malice.
  • Socrates questions Melitus about who knows the laws and who can instruct and improve the youth, with Melitus stating that judges, senators, and citizens all have the ability to improve them.
  • Socrates argues that Melitus is making an overstatement in order to win the trial, showing that he is not interested in the truth or justice.
  • Expertise is important when it comes to training, whether it's horses or human beings.
  • Socrates questions Mellitus about the charge of impiety and whether he teaches others to acknowledge different gods, ultimately clarifying that he believes in some gods but not the ones recognized by the state.
  • Socrates points out the contradiction in the formal charge against him, showing that he is a theist who believes in different gods, not an atheist.
  • Socrates argues that his accuser, Melitus, has contradicted himself and is motivated by personal envy and malice, rather than genuine concern for justice.
• 38:54 🤔 Socrates refuses to compromise on his philosophical beliefs, facing the risk of death and discussing the issues of piety, justice, and courage in his trial.
  • Let's compromise and tone things down instead of accusing you of corrupting people and being impious.
  • Socrates refuses to compromise on his philosophical beliefs, facing the risk of death and discussing the issues of piety, justice, and courage in his trial.
  • Socrates argues that courage is required in both physical and intellectual battles, and he has demonstrated his courage in military service and philosophical pursuits.
  • Socrates refuses to compromise on his mission of philosophy, choosing to obey God rather than the demands of the Athenian authorities.
  • Socrates emphasizes the importance of philosophy and virtue in improving the soul and the foundation of personal and public goods.
  • Socrates argues that he is like a gadfly, necessary to stir the city of Athens into action and improvement, and killing him would discourage others from speaking their minds and doing philosophical work.
• 48:53 🧐 Socrates defends himself in court, arguing that he should be rewarded, not punished, for his actions in seeking virtue and wisdom, ultimately leaving his fate in the hands of the citizens and God.
  • Socrates welcomes criticism and believes that those genuinely concerned with truth, justice, and goodness do not last long in politics, so he chooses to do philosophy privately.
  • Socrates defends himself by pointing to the high quality of individuals who have become his students and friends, ultimately leaving his fate in the hands of the citizens and God, and is found guilty in the end.
  • Socrates argues that he should be rewarded, not punished, for his actions in seeking to persuade others to seek virtue and wisdom.
  • Socrates believes he should be honored with free meals and care at the Criterion, but he knows it won't be accepted and expects backlash from the people present.
  • Socrates discusses possible punishments and argues against them, stating that he should be rewarded instead.
• 56:00 🤔 Socrates proposes a fine but is sentenced to death, raising questions about the conduct of trials in a democratic state and the consequences of people in power not valuing philosophy.
  • Socrates proposes a fine, but the jury votes for the death penalty, raising questions about the conduct of trials in a democratic state.
  • Many people in a democracy were not interested in Socrates' philosophy and wanted him punished, raising concerns about the consequences of such people having political power.
  • Socrates is not guilty, but the emotional response of the people in power leads to his death, raising questions about the kind of society that allows such injustice.
  • Socrates discusses death and predicts consequences for Athens after his execution.
  • Socrates argues that a society that does not welcome and value philosophers will decline, and he is unafraid of death because no harm can come to a good person.

------------------------------------- 1:2:24 2024-03-10T21:41:51Z