The Thirty-Six Questions - Supplement

The Thirty-Six Questions - Supplement

The Futurecrafters’ Council · A Xenological Survey of Sol-3

Two strangers, a sheet of paper and forty-five minutes: the instrument behind The Marriage Experiment, and the staircase a man walks on every date

❖

Two strangers sit down at a table in a psychology laboratory in 1997.

Between them lies a sheet of paper, and on it are thirty-six questions.

Three sets. Twelve questions each.

Each set asks for more than the last.

Forty-five minutes later they will report a closeness to match their closest relationships, and neither of them will have done anything but answer.

The Marriage Experiment filed the finding.

This supplement files the instrument.

The witness of that report, John Griffin of Life 2.0, called what the room produced the pink mist, and said scientists had found the formula for it.

This is the record of that formula: where it comes from, how it is run, what each set does to the two people climbing it, and where the version told in the video departs from the published one.

The questions themselves are a published research instrument, so the Council describes them set by set, in its own words, and links the full list at the end for any reader who wants to hold the sheet of paper.


A room built to make closeness

The procedure was developed by the psychologist Arthur Aron and four colleagues, and published in 1997 under a title that states its purpose exactly: “The Experimental Generation of Interpersonal Closeness.”

The researchers were not studying love.

They wanted a reliable way to produce closeness between strangers in a laboratory, so that closeness itself could be studied.

Griffin pictures the setting the pair walked into: scientists with clipboards, a room with two-way mirrors, two people who know they are being watched and cannot see by whom.

A situation that strange, he says, binds the people inside it before a single question is asked.

The rules are simple.

The two take turns: one reads a question aloud and both answer it before moving to the next, about fifteen minutes for each set and about forty-five minutes in all.

Two features carry the design, and the rest of this report follows them down the stairs.

The questions escalate, each set asking for more self-disclosure than the one before.

And the disclosure is reciprocal: whatever one party reveals,

the other reveals too, in the same minute.

The instrument has since been used in hundreds of studies — to create closeness on demand, to lower barriers between strangers, and in one program to improve understanding between police officers and the communities they serve.


The first twelve steps

The first twelve cost almost nothing to answer.

They ask about preferences and wishes: who the person would choose to spend an evening with, what an ideal day would hold, whether fame appeals.

Griffin puts it more plainly; at the start it is the favorite-color kind of thing, with “no intensity to it at all.”

The set touches lightly on habit and personal history, on what each is grateful for, and on what the two of them appear to have in common, and one item asks for a short account of the person’s life.

Even here, the set is quietly teaching the pair

to talk about themselves, and to listen.

By the twelfth question each has spoken about the self a dozen times and been listened to a dozen times, and has learned that the other will match whatever is offered.


Moving inward

The second twelve move inward; a few questions in, Griffin says, the list gets “ratcheted up a bit.”

They ask what the person would most want to know about the future, and what they have long dreamed of doing and have not done.

They ask for the greatest accomplishment, the most treasured memory and the worst one.

They ask what friendship means, what part love and affection play in the person’s life, and how they feel about their family and their childhood, including the relationship with the mother.

These are questions, in the witness’s words, that require some soul-searching and introspection, and they are answered to a stranger who has just answered the same thing.

Then one item has the pair take turns naming qualities they like in each other.

The procedure has begun to point the two at one another.

Neither has chosen to; the sheet of paper has chosen for them, and each step down has been only slightly larger than the step before.


What people ordinarily protect

The last twelve ask for what people ordinarily protect.

They ask for statements made jointly, as “we,” and ask each to finish a sentence about what they wish they had someone to share.

They ask for an embarrassing moment, and for the last time the person cried, in front of someone and alone; Griffin singles that one out as the question that “opens up the door.”

They turn to death: whose would be hardest to bear, and what would be regretted as unsaid if the person died tonight.

They ask each to tell the other, directly, what they already like about them.

And the set closes with a personal problem, shared, on which the partner is asked for advice, and asked to reflect back how the person seems to feel about it.

By the final question each party has disclosed, been heard,

been praised, and been asked for help.


FINDING:

The list is not a set of questions.

It is a staircase, and both parties are walked down it together,

one step at a time, at the same pace.


Forty-five minutes

The researchers compared pairs who used the thirty-six questions with pairs who made small talk for the same length of time.

The pairs who used the questions reported a markedly greater increase in closeness.

The detail the Council underlines is the size of it.

After forty-five minutes, the closeness these strangers reported matched

the average closeness that other participants reported in their closest existing relationships.

Some pairs went on to friendships, and in some cases to relationships.

For Griffin, the fact that the feeling “can be created in a laboratory says a lot.”

Griffin adds a caution a careful experimenter would respect: there is no control group, because every participant arrived already steeped in a culture built around romantic love, and nobody was raised outside it.

The Council filed that culture in Transcending the Simp Industrial Complex as an industry built on the pink water, one that sells a man his own submission and bills him again for the divorce.

The mist is always there, just under the surface.

The questions only open the valve.


FINDING:

Forty-five minutes of structured, reciprocal disclosure produced,

between strangers, the closeness of a closest relationship.

No legend is needed for that.


The story that grew

Two things in the popular version are not in the published procedure.

The first is the name.

In January 2015 the writer Mandy Len Catron published an essay in the New York Times, To Fall in Love With Anyone, Do This, describing how she tried the questions with an acquaintance.

The essay presented them as the thirty-six questions that lead to love, and the name stuck.

The second is the stare: the four minutes of unbroken eye contact comes from the essay’s account, not from the 1997 procedure, which contains no such step.

The witness in The Marriage Experiment told the story as it now travels: a session of an hour and a half to two hours, about a hundred and fifty pairs, the stare at the end, and a wedding to which the researchers were invited.

The published procedure runs forty-five minutes; the Council has not confirmed his count of pairs against the paper and enters it as his.

He also said, correcting himself, that the famous wedding is largely legend.

The record is mixed: the essay’s author has said that she and her partner did fall in love, and accounts of the original research mention pairs who went on to relationships.

The Council leaves the question of weddings open, because nothing in its finding depends on it.


The date is the laboratory

Griffin then makes the comparison that turns a curiosity into a warning.

On a date, Griffin says, two people sit across a restaurant table just as they did in the lab, hold eye contact just as they did in the lab, and ask each other questions just as they did in the lab.

It is the protocol, performed without a clipboard.

The easy questions run out, something more personal comes up, and a little taste of vulnerability enters the air.

At that moment, by his account, the room turns a deep pink, the prefrontal lobe begins to shut down, and the man starts running a boyhood fantasy instead of looking at the woman in front of him.

The Council has that suspension on file in Anglerfish Swimming in Pink Waters, where the male swims to the lamp, bites, fuses and dissolves.

Griffin knows it from the inside.

In the last days of eighth grade he found himself in the band room with the prettiest girl in the seventh grade, a girl he had never really known, and over two days of talk and games of Uno a very strong connection formed.

She hugged him and kissed his cheek at the end of the second day, and he carried her in his heart the whole long summer.

No sheet of paper was needed; the conditions were enough.

Three properties make the instrument work, and all three are present on an ordinary date.

Escalation: each disclosure is slightly larger than the last, so no single step feels like a risk.

Reciprocity: each disclosure is matched, so trust appears to have been earned.

Pace: the whole climb is completed in under an hour, long before either party has any other evidence about the other.


FINDING:

Every restaurant table runs the same three properties:

escalation, reciprocity and pace.

The date is the laboratory.


The man on the stairs

The Council found in How Dating Is Dying Around the World that the species’ men have, on continent after continent, quietly closed the ledger on dating.

The men who still sit down at the table are the ones the staircase is waiting for.

After two hours of questions, Griffin says, a man knows only what she was willing to tell him in two hours.

To know someone takes a year, or two, or three, of ordinary time.

Yet many men begin falling in love on date number one, and the instrument shows why: the climb is finished before the evidence has had time to arrive.

What a man may be asked to sign while the feeling is fresh, the Council has read clause by clause in Marriage is Suicide for Men.

Griffin’s counsel is one word, and it took him a moment to find it: not resilient, but vigilant.

A man who knows the three properties can recognize the staircase when he is on it.


FINDING:

The closeness waiting at the bottom was produced by the stairs.

It tells him nothing yet about the person standing beside him.

He can still walk down it.


Filed

The Marriage Experiment filed the finding; this supplement files the instrument.

Thirty-six questions in three sets of twelve, escalating and reciprocal, completed in about forty-five minutes, and a closeness at the end equal to a closest relationship.

The name and the stare were added later; the question of weddings stays open, because nothing in the finding depends on it.

Griffin signs off as he always does: stay healthy and, if you can, stay single.

Know the stairs, and let time be the evidence.

Will you walk with us?

Be More. Still You. Everywhere.

Carpe futurum ethicum.

Ad astra per aspera.

#AvoidThePinkMist

#TheThirtySixQuestions

Homo sapiens behavioral survey filed with the Futurecrafters’ Council

Source of record: The Thirty-Six Questions – Supplement, a Word document by Dr. Daneel Starsson, Architect / Author, companion to The Marriage Experiment - What They Don't Tell You (field testimony: John Griffin, Life 2.0, video).

Instrument of record: Aron, A., Melinat, E., Aron, E. N., Vallone, R. D., and Bator, R. J. (1997), “The Experimental Generation of Interpersonal Closeness: A Procedure and Some Preliminary Findings,” Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 23(4), 363–377. The questions are described here by set and theme and are not reproduced.

The full list of the thirty-six questions, as published for general use: 36 Questions for Increasing Closeness (Greater Good in Action, University of California, Berkeley).

Popularisation of record: Mandy Len Catron, “To Fall in Love With Anyone, Do This,” The New York Times (January 2015). Field testimony: “The Marriage Experiment: What They Don’t Tell You” (video).

Built on Daneel Starsson’s supplement, with the witness’s testimony from The Marriage Experiment and the Council’s own reading, in the Council’s house format; the witness’s account is rendered in the Council’s words, with brief phrases quoted as spoken.

Companion documents:
The Marriage Experiment - What They Don't Tell You
Transcending the Simp Industrial Complex
Anglerfish Swimming in Pink Waters
How Dating Is Dying Around the World
Marriage is Suicide for Men


0 comments

Leave a comment

#WebChat .container iframe{ width: 100%; height: 100vh; }